Historic Zoning Commission

Fourth and Gill H: Level II

4-F-22-HZ

Applicant Request

Proposed replacement of non-historic vinyl windows with double-hung, wood, two-over-two windows. Proposed windows will reflect original fenestrations except for the kitchen window on right side (northwest) elevation. Kitchen window is proposed to be increased in size so that header height and top window trim align with adjacent, full-height window. Wood trim to be repaired and replaced in-kind as necessary.

The provided specifications pertain to eight windows, for the first phase of a window replacement project. The applicant is proposing double-hung wood windows but also approval to use aluminum-clad wood windows on rear elevations in a later phase, if necessary.

CONDITION OF APPOVAL PER 4/21/2022 HZC MEETING: condition: 1) applicant to submit specifications for further phases of window replacement to staff for review.

Site Info

Two-story frame residence with a cross gable roof clad in asphalt shingles, an exterior of wood lap siding, and a continuous brick foundation. Decorative wood bargeboard and trim. Full-length, hipped-roof porch with a projecting front gable with cornice returns.

1. 617 Deery Street is a contributing resource to the Fourth and Gill National Register District and local overlay.

2. The windows proposed to be replaced are non-historic vinyl windows which overall, retain the original fenestrations and wood trim. Removal of these windows is appropriate. The window replacement project will take place in multiple phases; the initial phase is for eight windows.

3. The increase in header height for the kitchen window to align with the adjacent original window is appropriate. New window trim should reflect the materials and design of the existing.

4. The application contains quotes for two different window products. The proposed 2/2 double-hung wood windows meet the design guidelines. The applicant would like to request the approval of 2/2, double-hung, aluminum-clad wood windows on rear facing elevations in a later phase, pending cost estimates and availability. In the opinion of staff, the use of 2/2, double-hung aluminum-clad wood windows on the rear elevations is appropriate, as they are replacing non-historic vinyl windows. Due to the house's location, the rear elevations will not be visible from the right-of-way. Aluminum-clad wood windows can sufficiently replicate the muntin style and exterior depth, width, and profile of wood windows.